People Places Events In History Terms Organizations
Home Invites Members Groups Events Careers Videos News Photos Blogs Polls Forums Chat
Home > Blogs > Post Content

N. R. A. BACKED FEDERAL LAW BARS NEWTOWN SHOOTING VICTIMS FROM FILING LAWSUITS AGAINST GUN MAKERS (1976 hits)

HUFFINGTON POST, December 18, 2012 --The massacre of schoolchildren in Connecticut may yield new laws to limit the availability of military-style assault weapons. But one thing the latest tragedy will likely not produce: lawsuits against the company that manufactured the gun used in the killings.

Under a controversial law Congress passed seven years ago at the urging of the National Rifle Association, gun manufacturers are explicitly shielded from lawsuits that would seek to hold them liable for crimes committed with weapons they sold.

The 2005 law has drawn attacks from gun control advocates and constitutional scholars, who portray it as a powerful insulator for gun manufacturers, protecting them from the consequences of their lethal products. Why should gun manufacturers, they ask, enjoy a special liability protection not available to other companies that make potentially lethal products?

"Gun companies should be treated the same as any other company. There is no reason to give them special exemption from litigation," said Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the University of California, Irvine School of Law. "It is an outrageous piece of legislation."

Gun control advocates said they see a lawsuit in Alaska as their best hope to overturn the law. The Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence has challenged the constitutionality of the gunmaker shield law in a case involving a rifle taken from a gun shop by a convicted felon.

The origins of the shield law stem from a rising tide of litigation against the gun companies by crime victims. The most significant of these cases, and the one perceived as most damaging by the gun lobby, was brought by the families of the 13 people killed or seriously injured over a three-week span by the Washington, D.C.-area snipers, John Muhammad and Lee Malvo. The pair used a .223 Bushmaster semi-automatic rifle, similar to the one police said was used by Adam Lanza to kill 20 children in 6 adults with brutal efficiency in Newtown last week.

In 2004, Bushmaster and the gun dealer settled the lawsuit for $2.5 million in a case that gun control advocates hailed as a "major breakthrough."

The gun lobby agreed. The next year, following a fierce lobbying campaign by the NRA, Congress approved the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act, which offers a broad shield against lawsuits filed by victims of gun violence. The law does not provide 100 percent immunity, and the The Brady Center, which represented the families in the sniper shooting case, has challenged its constitutionality.

But in the years since, the law has done what the industry wanted: offer protection against litigation that targets it for liability when guns are used to commit crimes. The law also ended all existing lawsuits.

Wayne LaPierre, the NRA chief executive, hailed the legislative victory as a "historic day for the NRA and also for the Second Amendment." He said Congress "saved the firearms industry" by protecting it against "a blizzard of litigation to bankrupt the industry by legal fees."
In the Senate, the legislation won support from 15 Democrats, mostly from pro-gun states, including Sen. Harry Reid of Nevada, now the majority leader. President Barack Obama, then a senator from Illinois, and Vice President Joe Biden, a senator from Delaware, voted against the measure.

The language of the bill hewed closely to the NRA's position. "The possibility of imposing liability on an entire industry for harm that is solely caused by others is an abuse of the legal system," the law says.
The NRA did not respond to a request for comment on Tuesday.

The Brady Center also did not respond to a request for comment. After the law passed, a top lawyer vowed to "vigorously attack the law in courts." The Brady Center has continued to bring liability cases against gunmakers and sellers, citing exemptions in the law.

"Well-pleaded, carefully crafted cases can still proceed against irresponsible gun companies," wrote Daniel Vice, an attorney for the group, in a guide for lawyers who want to sue gun companies.

The Brady Center is currently handling a case it hopes to use to overturn the shield law. In 2006, Jason Coday, a drifter with a lengthy arrest record, shot and killed Simone Kim, a contract painter, outside of a grocery store in Juneau, Alaska, where he was working. The two men did not know each other.

Coday was prohibited under federal law from purchasing a firearm, but two days before the shooting he walked out of a gun store in Juneau with a Ruger .22-caliber rifle. Ray Coxe, the owner of the store, claimed Coday stole the gun when his back was turned and left $200 on the counter.

In 2008, Kim's family sued, alleging that Coxe knowingly allowed Coday to pay for the gun without first getting a background check. Two years later, a state judge dismissed the case, citing the lawsuit shield law, which protects gun shops and manufactures against civil claims arising from the "misuse of their products by others." The family appealed to the Alaska Supreme Court, which heard the case earlier this year. A decision is pending.

Even if the shield law were immediately repealed, it is unclear whether the Newtown shooting victims would have a case to make against Bushmaster, part of the Freedom Group of arms and ammunition makers owned by Cereberus Capital. (Cereberus said on Tuesday it was putting the Freedom Group up for sale because of the massacre.)

According to news reports, the Bushmaster assault-style weapon used in the shooting was legally purchased by Nancy Lanza, the gunman's mother. That wasn't true with the Washington, D.C. sniper case.

The sniper Bushmaster came from Bull's Eye, a gun shop in Washington state. Lee Malvo told investigators he stole the gun. Lawyers for the shooting victims claimed the retailer had acted negligently in allowing this to happen. Bushmaster, the victims claimed, acted recklessly in not ensuring that its dealer prevented ithe gun from falling into criminal hands.

The lawsuit cited a report by the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, which determined that Bull's Eye could not account for 238 guns that should have been in its inventory.
Posted By: Richard Kigel
Wednesday, December 19th 2012 at 12:16PM
You can also click here to view all posts by this author...

Report obscenity | post comment
Share |
Please Login To Post Comments...
Email:
Password:

 
"Gun companies should be treated the same as any other company. There is no reason to give them special exemption from litigation," said Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the University of California, Irvine School of Law. "It is an outrageous piece of legislation."

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/18/newtown-victims-lawsuits-nra-_n_2325721.html?icid=maing-grid10%7Chtmlws-main-bb%7Cdl1%7Csec1_lnk3%26pLid%3D247664

Wednesday, December 19th 2012 at 12:17PM
Richard Kigel
Thank you, Irma.

This is ridiculous. I would like to see our next congress revoke this law.

Wednesday, December 19th 2012 at 11:24PM
Richard Kigel
...ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO SAVING THE LIVES OF ALL OF OUR CHILDREN...BECAUSE WHEN IT COMES TO LOOKING OUT FOR THE BEST INTERESTS OF OUR CHLDREN WE BECOME TAHT FORCE THAT CAN MOVE MOUNTIANS.LOL!!!(SMILE)

...AND, PLEASE KEEP POSTING, MY FAVORITE PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHER.LOL!!!...
Thursday, April 10th 2014 at 6:47PM
GREAT POST RICH, AND HERE IS WHY BEING 70 IS A BLESSING, BECAUSE I KNOW FIRST HAND THE POWER OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE OUT TO SAVE LIVES...AND, REALLY MAKE SURE SOMETING LIKE THIS DOES NOT HAPPEN AGAIN...

NOT ONLY DID THE TOBACCO INDUSTRY TRY TO BLOCK LEGSLATIONS TO SUE THEM TO NOT SAY THEY COULD DO YOU HARM OR KILL YOU AND DID KILL YOU...

BUT SO DID THE AUTO INDUSTRY WITH A LITTLE TING LIKE PUTTING IN SEAT BELTS TO SAVE LIVES....

HOPEFULLY, WE USE OUR COMPUTERS TO DO RESEARCH AND TO BETTER BE ABLE TO BE PATIENT AND DIRECTLY INVOLVED IN THIS ALSO. (SMILE)
Thursday, April 10th 2014 at 6:47PM
RICH , SINCE I LIKE SIMPLE...THE ONLY THING THE LIBERALS HAVE TO DO TO GET THIS LAW PASSED IS TO TAKE THELASTWORD@MANBC'S PROGRAM ONTO THE FLOOR, TO THEIR PUBLIC SPEECHES,RALLYS THEFLOOR OF THESENATE AND OUSE AND THERE IS NO WAY THAY CAN LOOSE...SO GLAD YOU TOLD ME ABOUT LAWRENCE O'DONNELL BEING A WRITTER ON THEWEST WING TV SHOW...NOW I SURE WISH I HAD WATCHED THIS PROGRAM.LOL!!!

MSNBC IS HOT NOW AND I BELIEVE THEANCHORS ARE TIRED OF OUR PRESIDENT BEING SO DISRESPECTED LIKE THIS AND WHOW...VICE PRES. BIDEN IS NO SLOW LEEK IN BEING A TERROR TO THE RIGHT-WINGER'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EDUCATE!!!EDUCATE!!!EDUCATE!!!IS WHAT MSNBC HAS BEEN DOING FO RME SINCE TAHT SCHOOOL SHOOTING. (S-M-I-L-E)
Thursday, April 10th 2014 at 6:47PM
Please Login To Post Comments...
Email:
Password:

 
More From This Author
SERENA WILLIAMS WINS QATAR OPEN TO RETAKE NUMBER ONE RANK
ROSA PARKS FEATURED ON NEW POSTAGE STAMP
THE REAL STORY OF THE MOST “LIKED” PHOTO OF ALL TIME
WILL WHITE VOTERS DOOM OBAMA?
MEET ROCHELLE BALLANTYNE, 17, FROM BROOKLYN, ON THE ROAD TO BECOMING BLACK FIRST FEMALE CHESS MASTER
S.N.L. ELECTS A NEW PRESIDENT: JAY PHAROAH TAKES OVER ROLE OF IMPERSONATING OBAMA
SERENA, FACING DEFEAT, PULLS OUT STUNNING VICTORY FOR HER FOURTH U.S. OPEN CHAMPIONSHIP
THE MELISSA HARRIS-PERRY REVOLUTION WILL BE TELEVISED: DISSECTING PROVOCATIVE ISSUES IS HER FORTE
Forward This Blog Entry!
Blogs Home
Employer Showcase
>> more | add
Latest Jobs
Sports Medicine Assistant (Part-Time, 10 months) with Azusa Pacific University in Azusa, CA.
Visiting Assistant Professor in Early Modern Peninsular Spanish Literature and Culture with New York University in New York City, NY.
Assistant Editor, Physical Review A with American Physical Society in Ridge, NY.
Nonprofit Account Executive with EveryAction in Washington, DC.
2019 PGA TOUR Summer Internship Program with PGA TOUR in US, US.
>> more | add
Latest Member Activity
linda hasan just became a new member. 03:15PM
tazadaq shaah just posted a blog entitled 'the true secrets to success they refused to teach you in college: awakening melanated people'. 03:41AM
elynor moss just posted a blog entitled 'get to know the first black celebrity gospel fitness instructor: donna richardson'. 01:38PM
gregory boulware, esq. just commented on a blog entitled 'underground railroad safe house discovered in philadelphia'. 08:21PM
elynor moss just posted a blog entitled 'first black doctor in the united states: james mccune smith'. 05:15PM
bella m just became a new member. 01:17AM
elynor moss just posted a blog entitled 'mrs. fannie b. peck, founder of the national housewives’ league'. 01:06PM
elynor moss just posted a blog entitled 'nationwide insurance invested first!'. 12:21PM
tazadaq shaah just posted a video entitled 'soul not for sale 1099 o i d spiritual remedy redemption for the creditors yahawah' god's work'. 11:07AM
tazadaq shaah just posted a video entitled 'ill mind tazadaq 9 can you be successful without college /illuminati/migrant caravan'. 11:05AM
tazadaq shaah just posted a video entitled 'feminist, abortions roe vs wade revisited, trump , supreme court, illuminati :ill mind tazadaq 5'. 11:03AM
elynor moss just posted a blog entitled 'ethiopia making all the right moves as it elects first female president.'. 02:11PM
>> more | invite friends