People Places Events In History Terms Organizations
Home Invites Members Groups Events Careers Videos News Photos Blogs Polls Forums Chat
Home > Blogs > Post Content
 The New York Times Misleads Readers on Voter Fraud (293 hits)
After running a story about voter access laws last Sunday, the New York Times got some complaints from readers about its he-said-she-said treatment of whether voter fraud is a serious problem. Margaret Sullivan, the Times' public editor, asked the reporter and editor of the piece for their views:

The national editor, Sam Sifton, rejected the argument. “There’s a lot of reasonable disagreement on both sides,” he said. One side says there’s not significant voter fraud; the other side says there’s not significant voter suppression. “It’s not our job to litigate it in the paper,” Mr. Sifton said. “We need to state what each side says.”

Mr. Bronner agreed. “Both sides have become very angry and very suspicious about the other,” he said. “The purpose of this story was to step back and look at both sides, to lay it out.” While he agreed that there was “no known evidence of in-person voter fraud,” and that could have been included in this story, “I don’t think that’s the core issue here.”

This is a pretty remarkable response. I don't have a problem with giving both sides some air time, but by far the main focus of the voter access battle is stringent photo ID laws — and the only real justification for stringent photo ID laws is that it stops in-person voter fraud. (That is, the kind of fraud where people show up in person at a polling place and pretend to be someone they aren't. Even in theory, photo ID laws can't stop any other kind of fraud.) This means that the existence of in-person voter fraud is exactly the core issue. If you don't address the truth of that claim, you simply haven't done a good job of informing your readership.

And apparently Bronner knows this. He agrees that there's no known evidence of in-person voter fraud. So why on earth would he not make that clear in a story about voter ID laws? This wouldn't require him to take a stand on the laws themselves, only to point out to readers in his own voice that in-person voter fraud basically doesn't exist. They can then draw their own conclusions about whether voter ID laws are a good idea anyway and what the motivation for them is.

There are plenty of gray areas in the fight over voter access, which includes things like early voting hours, voter roll purging, and so forth. But on the specific subject of voter ID laws there are two clear facts: (a) the primary justification for the laws is in-person voter fraud, and (b) in-person voter fraud doesn't exist. Anyone writing about the subject is doing a disservice if they don't acknowledge this.

Posted By: David Johnson
Monday, September 17th 2012 at 11:29PM

Report obscenity | post comment
Share |
Please Login To Post Comments...
Email:
Password:

 
More From This Author
religions doctrailology
ROLAND MARTIN: ‘Dr. Dyson, West, Glaude, Perry — Do What’s Right For Black Folks!’
Michael Eric Dyson blasts Cornel West: ‘You ain’t that important’
Here is my free book club over 300 ebooks !!
14 Year Old Black Youth Invents Surgical Technique.
the Quran and Jesus
Watch: Paul Ryan tries to explain his ‘inner city’ remarks to a black constituent
Not Again! Troubled Taxpayer Lauryn Hill Slapped With ANOTHER Bill From IRS — For $867K
Forward This Blog Entry!
Blogs Home
Sponsored Opportunities
Employer Showcase
>> more | add
Latest Jobs
Director, Student Academic Services Outreach with Humboldt State University in Arcata, CA.
Coordinator II, Career Education with Fresno Unified School District in Fresno, CA.
Middle School Spiritual Life Director with Oaks Christian School in Westlake Village, CA.
Classroom & Small Events Technician - IMT (S391) with Azusa Pacific University in Azusa, CA.
Student Psychological Counselor with CUNY College of Staten Island in Staten Island, NY.
>> more | add
Latest Member Activity
darren desepoli just edited his profile. 09:51AM
mo carter just became a new member. 03:34AM
chelsey janae just posted a photos entitled 'chelsey janae'. 10:56AM
chelsey janae just became a new member. 10:33AM
patricia-toles peterson just posted a blog entitled 'legacy... i aspire to inspire before i expire !'. 11:13AM
patricia-toles peterson just joined a new club (). 10:10AM
patricia-toles peterson just posted a blog entitled 'be careful...'. 10:02AM
tony hall just became a new member. 03:14PM
tomeela west just became a new member. 03:31AM
patricia-toles peterson just joined a new club (black history book club). 11:05AM
patricia-toles peterson just joined a new club (poets and authors). 10:41AM
robert a. kearse just edited his profile. 03:07PM
>> more | invite friends